by 314 reviews.
Toshiba MG09ACA18TE 18 TB Hard Drive Review: A High-Capacity Powerhouse with a Few Quirks
The Toshiba MG09ACA18TE 18 TB Hard Drive is a high-capacity, enterprise-grade storage solution designed for professionals and businesses with demanding data needs. With its 18 TB capacity, 7200 RPM speed, and SATA/600 interface, this drive promises fast data transfer rates and reliable performance. It also incorporates Toshiba's advanced Flux Control Microwave-assisted Magnetic Recording (FC-MAMR) technology, which enhances data density and overall efficiency.
But how does it perform in real-world scenarios? Let’s dive into the pros and cons based on customer feedback.
Pros and Cons: A Detailed Breakdown
1. Performance and Speed
The Toshiba MG09ACA18TE delivers impressive performance for a traditional hard drive. Customers have praised its fast data transfer rates, with one user reporting 230 MB/s read/write speeds when used in an external USB-C enclosure. The 7200 RPM rotation speed ensures smooth operation, making it suitable for data-intensive tasks like 4K video editing and large-scale backups.
However, some users noted that the drive’s performance is not on par with SSDs, which is expected given its mechanical nature. Still, for bulk storage, it’s a solid choice.
2. Capacity and Compatibility
With 18 TB of storage, this drive is a game-changer for users who need massive amounts of space. One reviewer mentioned using it to store 4K video files, while another installed it in a NAS system to replace older 6 TB drives.
A common issue, though, is the MBR partition limitation. Some users mistakenly thought the drive was "fake" because it only showed 2 TB of available space. This is due to the outdated MBR format, which caps partitions at 2 TB. The solution is simple: convert the drive to GPT (GUID Partition Table) in Windows Disk Management.
3. Noise and Durability
Noise levels are a mixed bag. While some users found the drive to be no louder than other HDDs, others reported a noticeable increase in noise when using it in a NAS setup. The unique FC-MAMR technology might contribute to this, as it requires stronger magnetic fields for recording.
On the durability front, most users have had positive experiences. One reviewer ran two full scans and found no errors, confirming the drive’s reliability. However, there’s a concerning report of a drive failing after 10 months, with the user struggling to get support from Amazon, the seller, or Toshiba.
4. SMART Testing and Power Management
One significant drawback is the lack of a SMART conveyance test, which is commonly used to check for shipping damage. Instead, users must rely on the long test, which takes around 22 hours to complete. Unlike Seagate and WD drives, the Toshiba MG09ACA18TE doesn’t display progress during the test, and it won’t resume if power is lost.
This quirk might be a dealbreaker for users who prioritize detailed diagnostics and testing.
5. Packaging and Condition
While most customers received their drives in brand-new condition, there’s a troubling report of a drive being sold as new but showing 186 usage hours and 233 powered-on hours. This suggests that some units might be refurbished or used, raising concerns about the integrity of the supply chain.
Conclusion: Is the Toshiba MG09ACA18TE Worth It?
The Toshiba MG09ACA18TE 18 TB Hard Drive is a high-capacity, high-performance storage solution that excels in demanding environments. Its FC-MAMR technology and 7200 RPM speed make it a reliable choice for professionals and businesses. However, it’s not without its flaws.
Pros:
- Massive 18 TB capacity
- Fast data transfer rates (up to 230 MB/s)
- Reliable performance for bulk storage
- Energy-efficient design
Cons:
- No SMART conveyance test
- Long test lacks progress tracking and resume functionality
- Potential noise issues in NAS setups
- Reports of used drives being sold as new
Final Verdict: If you’re looking for a high-capacity hard drive for bulk storage or enterprise use, the Toshiba MG09ACA18TE is a strong contender. However, be cautious about the seller and ensure you’re purchasing from a reputable source to avoid receiving a used or refurbished unit. For users who rely heavily on SMART diagnostics, the lack of a conveyance test might be a drawback. Overall, it’s a great value for the price, but it’s not perfect.
Specification Toshiba MG09ACA18TE 18 TB Hard Drive - 3.5 Internal - SATA [SATA/600]:
Comments from Amazon:
NOTE: I've seen many people complain about drives because they're "fake" and only have 2048 GB. The drive is not fake. 2048GB is a limitation of the old MBR partition format, and if you initialize/format the drive with MBR you will see a 2TB partition! All you need to do to fix this is right click on the drive number in Windows Disk Management (get there from the start menu via Computer Management or "Create and format hard disk partitions"), click "Convert to GTP", and reformat the drive. I needed to replace several 6-year-old 6TB drives, and these were the natural choice. FC-MAMR is, of course, new tech, but I am expecting these to be reliable: a media that requires a stronger magnetic recording field means more energy is required to flip individual magnetic bits, so they should be less likely to flip on their own. Otherwise, the drives run exactly like you'd expect any other drive to run: plug it in and go. They aren't any noisier than any of my other drives and I have been transferring data to them non-stop since installation and haven't encountered any problems or unexpected behavior. Great job, Toshiba!
This drive gives me the space that I need to store alot of 4k video. Speed is expected of a non SSD but great for bulk storage.
The drives are best value for price (even still as of writing date) on Amazon. I Installed two x 18TB drives into my NAS which was excellent for space but did come at an noticeable noise level increase. At first I was concerned that the noises the drives made meant some fault but I have ran 2 full scans on the drives and have found no errors. So far everything working good. The noises likely come from the drives themselves and the way the "Flux Control Microwave-assisted Magnetic Recording" tech works.
Don't buy, defective after 10 months, Amazon won't help, seller won't help, Toshiba sends you to Amazon, and the circle continues.
Fast NAS HDD, installed it inOWC Elite Pro External USB C Case 230MB/s read/write on my MacStudio. No issues to date.
Packaging did not appear to manufacturer packaging, and Hard disk was purchased as NEW but reported as having 186 usage hours, and 233 powered on hours. This is clearly a used drive resold at NEW prices, hoping to be sold to someone who doesn't know how to check this.
I'm new to Toshiba drives (have lots of Seagate and WD), but these drives lack a SMART conveyance test, which is the first thing I run when I get new drives to check for shipping damage. Instead, I ran the long test on them. Here's another difference. On Seagate/WD, while a long test is running, there's an entry in the test results stating that a test is ongoing, and what % is left. And if a drive loses power, when it gets power again, it'll resume the test where it left off. On these drives, there's no entry in the test results until the test completes, and if the drive loses power, it'll forget it was testing. Other than those quirks, SMART output shows that these drives are brand new with 0 hours and the long tests completed on them without issue. FYI, the polling time recommended for the long test results was 15xx minutes (25-26 hours), but the tests actually finished in about 22 hours.