by 1 reviews.
Seagate BarraCuda 3TB Internal Hard Drive HDD Review: A Reliable Workhorse for Your Desktop
When it comes to internal hard drives, the Seagate BarraCuda 3TB Internal Hard Drive HDD is a popular choice for desktop users, gamers, and creative professionals. With its 3TB storage capacity, 7200 RPM speed, and 64MB cache, this 3.5-inch SATA 6Gb/s hard drive promises reliable performance and ample space for your files, games, and media. But how does it hold up in real-world usage? Let’s dive into the details based on customer experiences and my own testing.
Pros and Cons: What Customers Are Saying
Durability and Longevity
One of the standout features of the Seagate BarraCuda 3TB is its durability. A customer shared their experience of using five of these drives in a home NAS setup for 8 years, with the first drive failing only in 2025. Remarkably, the drives survived 3 years without active cooling, far exceeding the typical 3-5 year lifespan expected for NAS drives. This speaks volumes about the drive’s build quality and reliability.
However, not all experiences were flawless. Another user reported their drive failing after five years, with the drive making clicking noises before dying. While five years is still a respectable lifespan, it’s worth noting that hard drives can fail unexpectedly, so regular backups are essential.
Performance and Speed
The 7200 RPM speed and 64MB cache make the BarraCuda 3TB a solid performer. Benchmarks using Crystal Disk Mark showed read speeds of 195.1 MB/s and write speeds of 192.6 MB/s, which are impressive for a traditional HDD. Compared to older models, the new BarraCuda drives offer a noticeable improvement in speed, especially when the drive is less than 40% full.
That said, if you’re used to SSDs, the BarraCuda will feel slower. One user tried using it as a boot drive and quickly missed their SSD’s responsiveness. For optimal performance, it’s best to pair this drive with an SSD for your operating system and use the BarraCuda for storage or backups.
Value for Money
At around $25 per terabyte, the BarraCuda 3TB offers excellent value for its performance and capacity. Customers praised its affordability, especially during sales. For those looking to build a RAID setup or expand their storage without breaking the bank, this drive is a solid choice.
Usability and Compatibility
The BarraCuda 3TB is easy to set up and compatible with most desktop setups. Users reported no issues with mounting or formatting the drive to NTFS. Its 3.5-inch form factor makes it ideal for desktops, though it may not be suitable for laptops or compact builds.
Heat and Noise
While the BarraCuda performs well under normal conditions, heat can be a concern. One user noted that their drive may have failed due to excessive heat in their case. Proper cooling is essential to maximize the drive’s lifespan. As for noise, the drive operates quietly under light usage, but it can get louder during heavy read/write operations.
Final Thoughts: Is the Seagate BarraCuda 3TB Worth It?
The Seagate BarraCuda 3TB Internal Hard Drive HDD is a reliable and affordable storage solution for desktop users. Its durability, performance, and value for money make it a standout choice for those needing ample storage for games, media, or backups. While it may not match the speed of SSDs, it’s a dependable workhorse that delivers on its promises.
However, like all mechanical hard drives, it’s not immune to failure. Regular backups and proper cooling are essential to ensure longevity. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly HDD with solid performance, the BarraCuda 3TB is a great option. But for boot drives or speed-critical tasks, consider pairing it with an SSD for the best of both worlds.
Final Verdict
- Pros
Durable, excellent value, fast for an HDD, easy to set up. - Cons
Slower than SSDs, potential heat issues, occasional failures after 5+ years.
If you’re in the market for a reliable and affordable hard drive, the Seagate BarraCuda 3TB is a solid choice. Just remember to keep it cool and back up your data regularly!
Specification Seagate BarraCuda 3TB Internal Hard Drive HDD – 3.5 Inch SATA 6 Gb/s 7200 RPM 64MB Cache for Computer Desktop PC (ST3000DM008):
Comments from Amazon:
It's an affordable 3TB SATA HDD. That's it folks, the specs can be found in the documentation put out by Seagate if you need to know the exact expected speeds. They run a little faster than WD Blue, and only slightly slower than WD Black. Compare the spec sheets, it's a fun read :D These are waaaay more responsive than the 2 TB Seagate Surveillance drive they're replacing. These drives do not use shingled storage, so write times should be decent compared to NAS disks. It's a spinning disk that runs at 7200 RPM. It's certainly not the fastest thing on the market, but hey, I'm spoiled with SSD's for my boot disks. I have four of these drives. One I've been using for over a year now, the other three are going to be used for RAIDs eventually. Currently they are running backup duty. I haven't had any issue with any of them mounting correctly and taking NTFS formatting. New computer build will be getting four for a RAID 10 with a Ryzen CPU. I'll update when that happens? Ha, probably not. On a side note: I stuck one spare in a desktop as a boot disk... Oh man... I miss my SSD boot disks.
Really good product
This came in to me in a box within a box. Basically expected packaging. If you got your drive in any other form of packaging as reported by other users, you probably bought the drive from a different retailer. My order was fulfilled by Amazon. If it says it's being sold by another retailer, I wouldn't trust it. Even if their reputation is good. (Unless it's a retailer I know and trust) I ran some benchmarks using Crystal Disk Mark, and here are my results. Seagate drive NEW MODEL (The one shown here) Read: 195.1 MB/s Write: 192.6 MB/s Sandisk Z400m m.2 SSD Read: 558.5 MB/s Write: 187.3 MB/s Seagate drive OLD MODEL (32% Capacity Full) Read: 175.2 MB/s Write 138.2 MB/s In case most of you don't know, when a HDD reaches over 40% capacity, it starts to slow down dramatically. My old drive is 32% full so it's slightly slower than it should be. I'll be using this as a dedicated media storage and recording drive, and these results are very much what I need. I run Windows 10 and other programs on my SSD, my games are dedicated to my old Seagate drive, and now my media and video recordings will be dedicated to this new drive. If you're looking to buy this drive to run your Windows/Linux OS, then look towards getting and SSD for that instead, and using a seperate drive for games/media. If you can't afford the combo, see if you can get Seagates FireCuda line-up. It's built to have responsive Windows load times and keep the capacity of a normal HDD.
This 3 TB hard drive from Seagate spins at a very nice 7200 rpm giving typically 180 mb+ read performance. If you want reasonable performance from your HDD skip the 5400 rpm and 5900 rpm models that are commonly sold to consumers. What this means is that you can partition roughly the first 900 MB for a fast 'game/app' drive. Then use the rest of the volume for media storage that is slower - ie movies, pdfs, documents, etc. Very pleased with the value on this drive as I bought it at $75 so that's only $25 per terabyte of premium performance. Keep an eye out on these if they ever go on sale, well worth it!
Five years and it just died like a fart in the wind 3 terabytes was plenty. It may have been too warm in the case. RIP sweet soldier, you've saved your last half finished project But for real, I never put anything but static files on it and it died. I barely read off of it then it starts just clicky clicky done all of a sudden. Five years ish ain't so bad I guess Welp, all SSD now!
Cumpre o que promete
I bought five of these in early 2017 with manufacturing dates in May 2017. The year is 2025. They lived in my home NAS in ZFS-Raid1 with light usage for the last 8 years. I didn't notice my fan cooling my drives failed to get plugged in when I swapped my motherboard 3 years ago. The first one just failed now in 2025. 8 years of life with the last 3 years without any real cooling, beating the expected lifespan of a NAS HDD of 3-5 years by a long shot. I silvered in much larger modern drives to replace them all before another tanks on me, but I absolutely gotta salute these drives. They performed admirably. Five stars. Go Seagate.